TotallyStraight - Best Gay Porn Reddits

Revised Review of r/TotallyStraight.
I checked out r/TotallyStraight expecting a mix of amusement, eye rolling, and decent porn. Here’s my honest take.
What It Actually Is:
r/TotallyStraight is a Reddit subreddit billed as a space for “straight guys who love hardcore gay porn.” The premise is classic: hundreds of thousands supposedly of “totally straight” men who jack off to dude on dude action but maintain their heterosexual identity. It’s part porn dump, part support group for contested mostly straight sexualities.
Posts are mostly gay porn clips, GIFs, pics, and links everything from pro studio scenes to amateur stuff. The community adds a layer of personal stories, confessions, and affirmations that enjoying male bodies doesn’t make you gay. The rules are strict about no identity shaming: don’t tell people they’re in denial.

The Good Stuff:

Volume & Variety: There’s a decent flow of hot content. A lot of it features masculine, athletic, or “straight looking” guys, which clearly scratches a particular itch for the audience.
Community Vibe: It’s surprisingly chill in its own way. As a gay man, I appreciate the no-drama approach to porn sharing. Some threads are genuinely funny or relatable in their horniness.
Free & Accessible: Classic Reddit easy to browse on mobile or desktop, no paywall for the basics.

The Not So Good:
Here’s where my gaydar and slight frustration kicks in. As someone fully out and comfortable with my sexuality, the whole “I’m totally straight but…” performance feels exhausting and a bit dated. A lot of the appeal seems rooted in the taboo of “straight” guys doing gay things, which can come across as fetishizing denial or internalized homophobia. I’ve seen similar dynamics before it’s hot for some, but for me it sometimes reads as frustratingly close to the closet.
That said, I get the appeal for people exploring. Porn is fantasy, and if this framing helps guys get off without heavier identity stuff, more power to them. But as a gay reviewer, I’d rather see confident, unapologetic queer content than endless “no homo” disclaimers.

Pros Gay Lens:

Good source for masculine straight passing gay porn that some studios specialize in.
Low pressure environment compared to more overt gay subs.
Entertaining to lurk and observe the psychology of desire.

Cons Gay Lens:

Repetitive identity talk can feel like coping.
Content quality is inconsistent lots of reposts.
As a gay man, I sometimes feel like an outsider looking in on a performance that doesn’t fully resonate.
Reddit’s format means dealing with ads, bots, and link rot.

Final Verdict 4/5
r/TotallyStraight is a solid, long running niche spot if the “straight guys secretly into gay porn” trope turns you on. From my perspective as a gay guy, it’s more fascinating as a cultural phenomenon than a top tier porn destination. It delivers the visuals, but the mental gymnastics around labels can be tiring if you’re past that stage in your own journey.
If you’re a straight curious guy dipping your toes in, this might feel like a safe landing spot. If you’re already out and proud, you might get a few good faps out of it but probably won’t make it your main hub.
Bottom line: Worth a visit for the specific fantasy, but don’t expect it to replace dedicated gay porn sites. Check it out here: https://www.reddit.com/r/TotallyStraight/ strictly 18+.